Scoring scale for peer reviewers (PDF)
If you cannot open or read this document, you can ask for a different format.
Request a different format
Email email@example.com, telling us:
- the name of the document
- what format you need
- any assistive technology you use (such as type of screen reader).
Find out about our approach to the accessibility of our website.
This guide includes details of the four core criteria used on peer review forms along with assessment criteria for both academic and non-academic reviewers. It also maps the changes between the current scoring scale, which was introduced in 2011, and the earlier version.